Introduction to Biomechanics

Marcos Duarte
Laboratory of Biomechanics and Motor Control (http://demotu.org/)
Federal University of ABC, Brazil

Biomechanics @ UFABC

In [1]:
from IPython.display import IFrame
IFrame('http://demotu.org', width='100%', height=500)
Out[1]:

Biomechanics

The origin of the word Biomechanics is evident:

$$ Biomechanics := bios \, (life) + mechanics $$

Professor Herbert Hatze, on a letter to the editors of the Journal of Biomechanics in 1974, proposed a (very good) definition for the science called Biomechanics:

"Biomechanics is the study of the structure and function of biological systems by means of the methods of mechanics."
Hatze H (1974) The meaning of the term biomechanics.

Biomechanics & Mechanics

And Hatze, advocating for Biomechanics to be a science of its own, argues that Biomechanics is not simply Mechanics of (applied to) living systems:

"It would not be correct to state that 'Biomechanics is the study of the mechanical aspects of the structure and function of biological systems' because biological systems do not have mechanical aspects. They only have biomechanical aspects (otherwise mechanics, as it exists, would be sufficient to describe all phenomena which we now call biomechanical features of biological systems)." Hatze (1974)

Biomechanics vs. Mechanics

To support this argument, Hatze illustrates the difference between Biomechanics and the application of Mechanics, with an example of a javelin throw: studying the mechanics aspects of the javelin flight trajectory (use existing knowledge about aerodynamics and ballistics) vs. studying the biomechanical aspects of the phase before the javelin leaves the thrower’s hand (there are no established mechanical models for this system).

Branches of Mechanics

Mechanics is a branch of the physical sciences that is concerned with the state of rest or motion of bodies that are subjected to the action of forces. In general, this subject can be subdivided into three branches: rigid-body mechanics, deformable-body mechanics, and fluid mechanics (Hibbeler, 2012).
In fact, only a subset of Mechanics matters to Biomechanics, the Classical Mechanics subset, the domain of mechanics for bodies with moderate speeds $(\ll 3.10^8 m/s!)$ and not very small $(\gg 3.10^{-9} m!)$ as shown in the following diagram (image from Wikipedia):

Domains of mechanics

Biomechanics & other Sciences I

One last point about the excellent letter from Hatze, already in 1974 he points for the following problem:

"The use of the term biomechanics imposes rather severe restrictions on its meaning because of the established definition of the term, mechanics. This is unfortunate, since the synonym Biomechanics, as it is being understood by the majority of biomechanists today, has a much wider meaning." Hatze (1974)

Biomechanics & other Sciences II

Although the term Biomechanics may sound new to you, it's not rare that people think the use of methods outside the realm of Mechanics as Biomechanics.
For instance, electromyography and thermography are two methods that although may be useful in Biomechanics, particularly the former, they clearly don't have any relation with Mechanics; Electromagnetism and Thermodynamics are other branches of Physics.

Biomechanics & Engineering

Even seeing Biomechanics as a field of Science, as argued by Hatze, it's also possible to refer to Engineering Biomechanics considering that Engineering is "the application of scientific and mathematical principles to practical ends" [The Free Dictionary] and particularly that "Engineering Mechanics is the application of Mechanics to solve problems involving common engineering elements" [Wikibooks], and, last but not least, that Biomedical engineering is the application of engineering principles and design concepts to medicine and biology for healthcare purposes [Wikipedia].

Applications of Biomechanics

Biomechanics matters to fields of science and technology related to biology and health and it's also relevant for the development of synthetic systems inspired on biological systems, as in robotics. To illustrate the variety of applications of Biomechanics, this is the current list of topics covered in the Journal of Biomechanics:

In [2]:
from IPython.display import IFrame
IFrame('http://www.jbiomech.com/aims', width='100%', height=500)
Out[2]:

On the branches of Mechanics and Biomechanics I

Nowadays, (Classical) Mechanics is typically partitioned in Statics and Dynamics. In turn, Dynamics is divided in Kinematics and Kinetics. This classification is clear; dynamics is the study of the motions of bodies and Statics is the study of forces in the absence of changes in motion. Kinematics is the study of motion without considering its possible causes (forces) and Kinetics is the study of the possible causes of motion.

On the branches of Mechanics and Biomechanics II

Nevertheless, it's common in Biomechanics to adopt a slightly different classification: to partition it between Kinematics and Kinetics, and then Kinetics into Statics and Dynamics (David Winter, Nigg & Herzog, and Vladimir Zatsiorsky, among others, use this classification in their books). The rationale is that we first separate the study of motion considering or not its causes (forces). The partition of (Bio)Mechanics in this way is useful because is simpler to study and describe (measure) the kinematics of human motion and then go to the more complicated issue of understanding (measuring) the forces related to the human motion.

Anyway, these different classifications reveal a certain contradiction between Mechanics (particularly from an engineering point of view) and Biomechanics; some scholars will say that this taxonomy in Biomechanics is simply wrong and it should be corrected to align with the Mechanics. Be aware.

The future of Biomechanics

(Human) Movement Science combines many disciplines of science (such as, physiology, biomechanics, and psychology) for the study of human movement. Professor Benno Nigg claims that with the growing concern for the well-being of humankind, Movement Science will have an important role:

Movement science will be one of the most important and most recognized science fields in the twenty-first century... The future discipline of movement science has a unique opportunity to become an important contributor to the well-being of mankind.
Nigg BM (1993) Sport science in the twenty-first century. Journal of Sports Sciences, 77, 343-347.

And so Biomechanics will also become an important contributor to the well-being of humankind.

Biomechanics and the Biomedical Engineering at UFABC (2017) I

At the university level, the study of Mechanics is typically done in the disciplines Statics and Dynamics (rigid-body mechanics), Strength of Materials (deformable-body mechanics), and Mechanics of Fluids (fluid mechanics). Consequently, the study on Biomechanics must also cover these topics for a greater understanding of the structure and function of biological systems.

Biomechanics and the Biomedical Engineering at UFABC (2017) II

The Biomedical Engineering degree at UFABC covers these topics for the study of biological systems in different courses: Ciência dos Materiais Biocompatíveis, Modelagem e Simulação de Sistemas Biomédicos, Métodos de Elementos Finitos aplicados a Sistemas Biomédicos, Mecânica dos Fluidos, Caracterização de Biomateriais, Sistemas Biológicos, and last but not least, Biomecânica I & Biomecânica II.

How much of biological systems is in fact studied in these disciplines varies a lot. Anyway, none of these courses cover the study of human motion with implications to health, rehabilitation, and sports, except the last course. This is the reason why the courses Biomecânica I & II focus on the analysis of the human movement.

More on Biomechanics

The Wikipedia page on biomechanics is a good place to read more about Biomechanics:

In [3]:
from IPython.display import IFrame
IFrame('http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biomechanics', width='100%', height=400)
Out[3]:

History of Biomechanics

Biomechanics progressed basically with the advancements in Mechanics and with the invention of instrumentations for measuring mechanical quantities and computing.

The development of Biomechanics was only possible because people became more interested in the understanding of the structure and function of biological systems and to apply these concepts to the progress of the humankind.

Aristotle (384-322 BC)

Aristotle was the first to have written about the movement of animals in his works On the Motion of Animals (De Motu Animalium) and On the Gait of Animals (De Incessu Animalium) [Works by Aristotle].

Aristotle clearly already knew what we nowadays refer as Newton's third law of motion:
"For as the pusher pushes so is the pushed pushed, and with equal force." [Part 3, On the Motion of Animals]

Aristotle & the Scientific Revolution I

Although Aristotle's contributions were unvaluable to humankind, to make his discoveries he doesn't seem to have employed anything similar to what we today refer as scientific method (the systematic observation, measurement, and experiment, and the formulation, testing, and modification of hypotheses).

Most of the Physics of Aristotle was ambiguous or incorrect; for example, for him there was no motion without a force. He even deduced that speed was proportional to force and inversely proportional to resistance [Book VII, Physics]. Perhaps Aristotle was too influenced by the observation of motion of a body under the action of a friction force, where this notion is not at all unreasonable.

Aristotle & the Scientific Revolution II

If Aristotle performed any observation/experiment at all in his works, he probably was not good on that as, ironically, evinced in this part of his writing:

"Males have more teeth than females in the case of men, sheep, goats, and swine; in the case of other animals observations have not yet been made". Aristotle The History of Animals.

Leonardo da Vinci (1452-1519)

Vitruvian Man
Contributions of Leonardo to Biomechanics:

  • Studies on the proportions of humans and animals
  • Anatomy studies of the human body, especially the foot
  • Studies on the mechanical function of muscles

    *"Le proporzioni del corpo umano secondo Vitruvio", also known as the Vitruvian Man, drawing by Leonardo da Vinci circa 1490 based on the work of Marcus Vitruvius Pollio (1st century BC), depicting a man in supposedly ideal human proportions (image from Wikipedia).

Giovanni Alfonso Borelli (1608-1679)

Borelli

  • The father of biomechanics; the first to use modern scienfic method into 'Biomechanics' in his book De Motu Animalium.
  • Proposed that the levers of the musculoskeletal system magnify motion rather than force.
  • Calculated the forces required for equilibrium in various joints of the human body before Newton published the laws of motion.


    Excerpt from the book De Motu Animalium.

The International Society of Biomechanics

The biomechanics community has an official scientific society, the International Society of Biomechanics, with a journal, the Journal of Biomechanics, and an e-mail list, the Biomch-L:

In [4]:
from IPython.display import IFrame
IFrame('http://biomch-l.isbweb.org/forums/2-General-Discussion', width='100%', height=400)
Out[4]:

Examples of Biomechanics Classes around the World

In [5]:
from IPython.display import IFrame
IFrame('http://pages.uoregon.edu/karduna/biomechanics/bme.htm', width='100%', height=400)
Out[5]:

Problems

  1. Go to Biomechanics Classes on the Web to visit websites of biomechanics classes around the world and find out how biomechanics is studied in different fields.
  2. Find examples of applications of biomechanics in different areas.
  3. Watch the video The Weird World of Eadweard Muybridge to learn about Eadweard Muybridge, an important person to the development of instrumentation for biomechanics.
  4. Think about practical problems in nature that can be studied in biomechanics with simple approaches (simple modeling and low-tech methods) or very complicated approaches (complex modeling and high-tech methods).
  5. What the study in the biomechanics of athletes, children, elderlies, persons with disabilities, other animals, and computer animation for the cinema industry may have in common and different?
  6. Visit the website of the Laboratory of Biomechanics and Motor Control at UFABC and find out what we do and if there is anything you are interested in.
  7. Is there anything in biomechanics that interests you? How could you pursue this interest?

References